Monthly Archives: October 2007

AANews Opinion: EMU doesn’t suck (this week); Fallon still not helping matters

There was a nice editorial in the Ann Arbor News yesterday, “Achievements at EMU deserving of spotlight,” which praises Professor Rob “#1 on Ratemyprofessor.com and beyond” Citino and student innovator Joesph “Wall Street Journal 2007 Achievement Award” Venuto.  It’s kind of a re-run of the articles they had in the paper earlier in the week, but it’s still nice to hear again.  “Recent recognition for a professor and a student at Eastern Michigan University bring welcome attention to the quality of work being done there,” to quote from the editorial.

Speaking of AANews editorials on EMU:  there was one on Sunday that I forgot to link to earlier in the week, “Fallon lawsuit slows EMU’s efforts to heal.”  I am sure EMUTalk.org readers are well-aware of Fallon’s suit, one where he says he wants to be reinstated as president.   By the way, one of the reasons why Fallon is suing is “emotional distress.”  I wonder if we can organize a class-action counter-suit?

Continue reading

MRSA case on EMU’s campus reported

 I just received this email, which appears to have gone campus-wide, and it looks like the very-antibiotic-resistant version of a staph infection that has been popping up around the country more and more lately has been found here at EMU.  Only one case has been found so far, but this stuff is bad news.   The email is below…

Continue reading

Marshall Poe Lecture Thursday, “Wikipedia: Academia’s Friend of Foe?”

FYI for everyone: come see Marshall Poe’s lecture on Thursday, 7 pm, in 201 Pray-Harrold Hall. His talk, titled “Wikipedia: Academia’s Friend or Foe?” is the first of a four part series of lectures titled “Wikipedia: The Democratization of Knowledge or the Triumph of Amateurs?” that will take place in the winter 2008 term. Marshall T. Poe, who is the 2007-2008 McAndless Scholar in the College of Arts and Sciences, is one of the leading scholars in the world of early and medieval Russian history. He has fervently encouraged the increase of online materials in Russian history (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marshall_Poe) and he has increasingly turned his attention to the use and abuse of the internet as a scholarly tool. His recent articles in The Atlantic Monthly describe the tremendously popular online encyclopedia Wikipedia (see “The Hive”), and he has a book coming out titled WikiWorld: The Globalization of Knowledge in the 21st Century.

One of Two Jurors Explains the Vote to Acquit

See the article, “Juror explains why she voted to acquit,” which is very thorough.  The quote that is most interesting reads:

“Codrington said she could not, and did not, find Orange Taylor III innocent.  She found him not guilty. And the two, she said, are not the same.”

 There is also a reaction piece, “Reaction is mixed on EMU campus to mistrial,” with quotes from several EMU students.

Mistrial for Taylor

From the AA News, “Jury deadlocked in EMU murder trial.”

A judge has declared a mistrial in the murder case against a former Eastern Michigan University student after the jury reported it was hopelessly deadlocked following two-and-a-half days of deliberations.

Orange Taylor III was ordered remanded to the county jail to await a new trial on charges he sexually assaulted and murdered 22-year-old Laura Dickinson in her Hill Hall dorm room last December.

Personally, I find it hard to believe that a jury could see any “reasonable doubt” in this case, but there you have it. I have to assume that the prosecution will attempt to try the case again, but I’m also wondering what happens to the other charges like home invasion, burglary, etc.

Halloween at EMU?

A few months ago, there was some discussion on this blog on what’d be the best way or place to celebrate Halloween at EMU. Anybody know what plans if any are being made or implemented? Eight days to go…..

from the Grand Rapids Press

This is from today’s newspaper in Grand Rapids.

“Slain student’s hometown waits and remembers”
Posted by Tom Rademacher | The Grand Rapids Press October 23, 2007 09:01AM

REX LARSEN/GRAND RAPIDS PRESS

HASTINGS – This is a town that understands the third chapter of Ecclesiastes. “A time to be born and a time to die … a time to weep and a time to laugh … a time for everything …”

Verses one through nine, in fact, can be read in the coffeehouse where Laura Dickinson worked, on a frame displaying photos snapped by the young woman whose death now draws this community close, and whose suspected killer walked into a courtroom today to await a jury’s third day of deliberations.

Guilty?

Not guilty?

In the end, what counts for some isn’t so much whether Orange Taylor III is convicted in Laura Dickinson’s death, but how this Barry County community reacts.

No matter the decision, “This Hastings community will come together,” said Marion Christensen, 19, as she sipped a drink outside the State Grounds coffeehouse owned by Laura’s father, Robert Dickinson.

“Faith reaches out to faith,” added Jan Boulter, inside the coffeehouse with friend Barb Daugherty.

“We’ve all changed,” Boulter said of the effect Laura’s death has had on this town.

“There’s the shock, the disappointment. But there’s also the pride you take in your community in how it responds.

“Tragedy does that.”

This was a blond-haired girl whose dad had nicknamed her “the Queen of Hastings” for her free spirit and endearing Pollyanna attitude.
Continue reading

Two good news EMU stories in the AA News: Citino and Venuto

I don’t know who had to pay off who to get not one but two good news stories about EMU into the Ann Arbor News on the same day, but there they were:

  • “EMU history professor wins high praise,” which is another story about history professor Rob Citino and his recognition by Ratemyprofessor.org, mentioned here on EMUTalk.org last week.  The whole stats problem of that site aside, congrats once again to Rob and it is an excellent write-up about his great work at EMU over the years.
  • “Success is in the cards for EMU senior Entrepreneur wins national award” is about EMU student Joe Venuto who was awarded a Wall Street Journal 2007 Achievement Award for exceptional students based on variety of entrepreneurial ventures, most one that involves buying and selling “sports memorabilia:”  lots of various cards, including a sizable number of NASCAR trading cards (really?  those exist?).  Anyway, big congratulations to Joe!

Taylor verdict could come at any moment

I’ve been watching CourtTV this morning, as they are on a “verdict watch” for the Taylor trial.  The jury is in deliberations and could issue their verdict at any time today.  The speculation on CourtTV is very interesting, as there has been alot of discussion towards a possible indictment as a result of a lot of so-called “missing” evidence on the method of the victim’s death.  The pundits are saying that a natural cause death (heart attack, etc) has not been ruled out through the trial, and there is little to no evidence of any violent act occurring (i.e. no bruises, marks on the face as a result of strangulation/suffocation).

My question is that, if the verdict were to come out making Taylor not guilty for murder, would that open up a new discussion on the severity of the whole “cover-up” situation?  Would we still believe that a murder occurred?

On another note, I’m still bothered by this whole ‘guilty until proven innocent’ situation that Greg Jones has posted about several days ago.  Reporters and people engaged in general discussion keep talking about “the killer” and “when Taylor killed her” when they are discussing the trial and turn of events.  As far as the trial has gone so far, it’s hard to tell if there even is a killer, especially when the ‘medical experts’ on stand did not even rule a natural death out as a cause.

From Laura’s Dad/sharelaurashope.com

Bob Dickinson (Laura’s dad) posted the following comment in an earlier thread and said it was okay for me to repost it here:

It’s all said and done now in the court room. Nothing left but the verdict. After being there all week, home now and exhusted, I’m still left with nothing but an empty room, a broken spirit and a hope each tomorrow gets easier to get through.

This part of the process will be over soon. We will continue through the next unknown number o years always wondering what an impact Laura would have had in this world. We will do everything we can do to make a possitive statement for Laura’s life. www.sharelaurashope.com is the first of many I’m sure.

Laura was quite simply put, amazing!

There’s no way that I can come close to writing something as heartfelt and as touching as what Mr. Dickinson has written here, so I’m not going to try. And while this too is probably stating the obvious, I hope the Dickinsons know they have my condolences and the condolences of everyone in the EMU community.

Share Laura’s Hope is a campaign to raise money for children of HIV victims in Africa, a cause that Laura was involved in over the past few years, according to site. Obviously, it’s a great cause, and I urge all of you to make a donation in Laura’s memory.