Well, this is kind of interesting: our friends at Eagle Totem alerted me the other day to this post, “Crimes and Misdemeanors.” Jeremy Rosenberg had a chance to sit down with Athletic Director Heather Lyke to talk about the the recent somewhat late suspension from the football team (and also the university) of Darius Scott, Jay Jones, and Quincy Jones and this is what he wrote.
Read what he posted over there, but here’s a quote:
She said that, “University policy is [that] we’re not going to make a public … statement about any misdemeanor.” Lyke went on to clarify that this directive does not originate from the Athletic Department, that is comes from the University.
This is the distinction, readers. According to Lyke, the Athletic Department had a statement crafted and ready to go if the charge was changed to a felony. A distinct line is drawn between a misdemeanor and a felony, Lyke said that there are “different paths that we have to go down” depending on the nature of the charge. A felony charge triggers a series of actions that simply do not occur in the case of a misdemeanor.
You know how I said something was fishy about all this? Turns out the fishiness is coming from the Washtenaw County Prosecutor’s Office. In short, how is this crime not a felony? Not that I’m rooting for Scott, Jones, and Jones to have a felony on their record, quite the contrary, but they put this dude in the hospital with a fractured orbital bone and multiple lacerations.
In other words, according to Lyke, these guys weren’t charged with a felony and that’s why the AD and such didn’t have to come forward.
Rosenberg said that Lyke seemed sincere and wanting to be open about all this, but there are still two things that I have to say nag at me a bit. First, why is this not a felony? Rosenberg blames the Prosecutor’s Office and maybe he’s completely right about that. But according to what Lyke told Rosenberg, the AD office knew that there was a crime but they didn’t know who committed the assault until the three players got together with Coach Creighton, who then persuaded them to turn themselves in.
So here’s my question: did these guys get a sort of “preemptive plea bargain” of calling the assault a misdemeanor rather than a felony as a result of turning themselves in? And I wonder if anyone in the AD’s office got on the phone with someone in the Washtenaw Prosecutor’s Office (and after the Reed killing, there are probably people in both offices who know each other well) and said something like “Look, these guys were good friends with Demarius and they guy they beat was the cousin to the scumbag who killed him. So maybe if they turn themselves in we can look the other way on this whole felony thing?”
And second, if this is indeed just a misdemeanor– like getting caught with drugs or alcohol in your dorm room– how does EMU kick these guys completely out of school?
So it seems to me that Lyke’s answers actually raise some other questions.